Nose:  Butterscotch on charcoal

Palate: This is a wierd one.  It's common for me to find a great malt with a disappointing finish.  Here the finish is everything. For the first second it's just plain faint charcoal.  Then exhale... magic.  The finish has everything a Port Ellen has (butterscotch,redhots, sweetness), on a base of fresh tar.

Yummy! B+/A- 

Nose of peat smoke and bubblegum. Palate of delicious peat smoke and bubblegum. Finish of more peat smoke and bubblegum. Yep, there ya go. But wow, I like this a lot! Massively drinkable for something so peaty. Excellent! It's just great how this maintains such superb drinkability while being massively peated.

(Note to Andy: although the finish does drop off quickly while adding nothing, that just makes this all the more drinkable for me, in the best of ways).